The first section acts as an introduction to the subject of componential analysis, and what is meant by this term. Componential analysis of the cultural terms in the. Cultural implications for translation by kate james. This is a practical coursebook for the understanding of how meanings are expressed in the english language at the word level and the sentence level.
The validity of componential analysis in translating metaphor. The functions of componential analysis to the translation of. As an effective approach for analyzing semantic components, componential analysis is an effective way to break down semantic components of words and make them easily understood. Translation and language by peter fawcett, paperback. Translation equivalence was a fundamental concept in translation studies in the 1960s and 1970s.
Jan 01, 1979 excellent overview of componential analysis. This major work by professor newmark is a textbook and a handbook of translation for english and foreign students working alone or on courses at degree and postgraduate level. The paradigm of most componential research consists of selfreport studies. This book is a stepbystep guide to the main notions of semantics, covering a large number of topics such as componential analysis, types of meaning, meaning relations, semantic unacceptability, selectional and collocational restrictions, types of emotional experience, types of synonymy, types of. Componential analysis article about componential analysis.
This study aims to give an account for the subject of componential analysis of meaning as it is considered to be an important approach to the study of. This book assesses both sides of the relationship, tracing the very real contributions that linguists have made to translation studies and at the same time recognizing the limitations of many of their approaches. Part 1 of the study presents the theoretical framework on which the. Componential analysis revisited componential analysis ca is a brainchild of structuralism. In his book method and theory in the semantics and cognition of kinship. This book is an introduction to semantics for students and researchers who are new to the field, especially those interested in arabicenglish translation and arabicenglish contrastive studies. Componential analysis is a method typical of structural semantics which analyzes the components of a words meaning.
As a consequence, entirely different ways to describe meaning were developed. Componential analysis focuses on the research of notional lexicalsemantic. Using componential analysis to evaluate translation results. We could not read literature in translation, it was argued, without asking ourselves if linguistic and cultural phenomena really were translatable and exploring in some depth the concept of equivalence. Text analysis in translation has become a classic in translation studies. With introductory essays prefacing each section, the book places a wide range of seminal and innovative readings within their thematic, cultural. Dictionary of translation studies, by mark shuttleworth and moira cowie routledge, 1997 is an excellent resource for bible translators. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In this case, componential analysis serves as a solution. Longerstanding international translation studies journals such as babel the netherlands and meta canada, first published in. Translation procedures, strategies and methods the translating procedures, as depicted by nida 1964 are as follow.
Semantics ii userpage componential analysis is effective when it comes to representing similarities and differences among words with related meanings it allows us to group entities into natural classes similar to phonology. Componential analysis of kinship terminology ebook by v. An introduction to discourse analysis and translation studies 354 translators and asterix have something in common. Comparative linguistics and contemporary translation studies. Unlike many books on semantics, this one is written in an accessible style that does not require a mastery of the semantic jargon. An introduction to discourse analysis and translation studies 356 comics are part of the cultural, intellectual and affective system of many of us. Componential analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. Structural semantics and the componential analysis were patterned on the phonological methods of the prague school, which described sounds by determining the absence and presence of features. Eugene albert nida was born in oklahoma city, oklahoma on november 11, 1914. Translation for componential analysis in the free englishitalian dictionary and many other italian translations. She translates from several languages and lectures on aspects of translation all over the world. Nov 26, 2016 the use of componential analysis in translation 1. An analysis of this nature becomes possible if the concepts of phonological extension systems and redundancyfree representations are introduced. Componential analysis is the analysis of words through structured sets of semantic features.
General cultural implications for translation language and culture may thus be seen as being closely related and both aspects must be considered for translation. Componential analysis also shows that no word has the exactly same feature and same meaning, it is. Up and down, for example, are related in that they both describe vertical directions, one in one direction call it. Based on a functional approach to translation and endebted to pragmatic text linguistics, it suggests a model for translation oriented sourcetext analysis applicable to all text types and genres independent of the language and culture pairs involved. Translation and interpretation australian islamic library. An academic discipline translation studies is an academic discipline which concerns itself with the study of translation 7. Nida 1975 says that one aspect of language which complicates the study of meaning is that even a single meaning of a term may include enormous range of. The method thus departs from the principle of compositionality. Componential theory an overview sciencedirect topics. Participants report reallife events in which they have experienced a given emotion and its translations in different cultures, and then rate their experience in that same situation with respect to several emotion components. An alternative to componential analysis as a mode l of analysis in combination with the general procedural model for meaning determination is a model of ana lysis with lexicalsystemlike structures. The approach is based upon the belief that the meaning of a word can be dissected into meaning components, called semantic features. When susan bassnetts translation studies appeared in the new accents series, it quickly became the essential. Componential analysis and the study of meaning 11940.
Componential analysis of lushai phonology john benjamins. Componential analysis tests the idea that linguistic categories. Componential analysis provides an insight into the meaning of words and a way to study the relationships between words that are related in meaning. Nida november 11, 1914 august 25, 2011 was a linguist who developed the dynamicequivalence bibletranslation theory and one of the founders of the modern discipline of translation studies. Making judgments of the semantic and syntactic approximations. Linguistic semantics is also used by anthropologists called ethnoscientists to conduct formal semantic analysis componential analysis to determine how expressed signsusually single words as vocabulary items called lexemesin a language are related to the perceptions and thoughts of the people who speak the language. Click download or read online button to acomponentialanalysisofmeaning book pdf for free now. Componential analysis provides an insight into the meaning of words and a way to study the relationships between words that are related in. Pdf the componential analysis of literary meaning researchgate. A coursebook on translation by mona baker, translation studies by susan bassnett, the translation s. Componential analysis and the study of meaning 11940 words. It was first developed by linguists such as nida 1975a. With introductory essays prefacing each section, the book places a wide range of seminal and innovative readings within their thematic, cultural and historical contexts.
Thus, it reveals the culturally important features by which speakers of the language distinguish different words in a semantic field or domain ottenheimer, 2006, p. Translation studies and linguistics have been going through a lovehate relationship since the 1950s. A coursebook for students of english as a foreign language is an essential resource for all undergraduate students studying semantics. This book presents the first computer program automating the task of componential analysis of kinship vocabularies. Russian approaches shveitser and retsker translation as analogy translation as adequacy concretization logical derivation antonymic translation compensation the view from canada vinay and darbelnet. Jan 01, 2014 taibah university, saudi arabia semantics. Componential analysis which studies meanings of lexical items in terms of meaning 2 components or features can help us to. Sl word is transferred directly to tl transpose by sounds nabokov. View componential analysis research papers on academia. Componential analysis words can be analyzed and described in terms of their semantic components, which usually come in pairs called semantic oppositions. When considering the translation of cultural words and notions, newmark proposes two opposing methods. Notesthoughts seminar in translation studies tyler.
The development of equivalence, nida s equivalence theory. A componential analysis of meaning new books in politics. It has caused heated debate and views towards it vary from person to person. This study aims to weigh the use of componential analysis for evaluating the accuracy of the translated words. The second term emphasizes that the aim of componential analysis is to decompose the meaning of the word into its sensecomponents. There are many other factors that affect meaning and determine the choice of translation such as the linguistic cotext and the context in which the. In the late 1970s a new academic discipline was born.
Componential analysis is a semantic process in which a words meaning is reduced to its ultimate contrastive elements, or minimal components. The aim of this essay is to present a phonological analysis of lushai, a tibetoburman language spoken in the mizoram province of india, in terms of componential features applying as mutation rules to the morphophonological level. He became a christian at a young age, when he responded to the. She has published extensively on translation, and her best known books include reflections on translation 2011, constructing cultures written with andre lefevere 1996 and postcolonial translation coedited with harish trivedi 1999. Language and culture may thus be seen as being closely related and both aspects must be considered for translation.
Translation and language by peter fawcett, paperback barnes. Despite many articles and books written about terminology there are still many people who without previous familiarizing themselves with the content of a particular termterms, maybe as a result of frequent hearing itthem, use the terms incorrectly. Componential analysis gave birth to various models in generative semantics, lexical field theory, and transformational grammar. Componential analysis feature analysis or contrast analysis is the analysis of words through structured sets of semantic features, which are given as present, absent or indifferent with reference to feature. Like componential analysis, relational semantics as introduced by lyons 1963 develops the idea of describing the structural relations among related words, but restricts the theoretical vocabulary that may be used in such a description. A componential analysis ofmeaning download a componential analysis ofmeaning ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Although language is involved in both, so the affinity of these disciplines is clear, the linguistic tradition led at times to overlooking the particularities of translation. The semantic domain where componential analysis was first used with some success was kinship terminology.
The functions of componential analysis to the translation. Competence combination of skills, knowledge, aptitudes, and attitudes and the disposition to learn as well as knowhow linguistic competence. Translation and language 1st edition peter fawcett. Some scholars describe it as the nature and content of the relationship between the source language and target language texts. Acomponentialanalysisofmeaning download acomponentialanalysisofmeaning ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Based on input from various linguistic and cultural contexts, each. Fundamentals of translation clear and concise, this textbook provides a nontechnical introduction to the basic and central concepts of translation theory and practice, including translation briefs, parallel texts and textual functions, cohesion and coherence, and old and new information. On one hand, componential analysis gave birth to various models in generative semantics, lexical field theory and transformational grammar. Componential analysis method fenglei zhang research paper. Translation studies is an academic discipline which concerns itself with the study of translation7. Their main focus was the scientific study of literature. Holmess the name and nature of translation studies. Click download or read online button to a componential analysis ofmeaning book pdf for free now.
Read componential analysis of kinship terminology a computational perspective by v. Nida november 11, 1914 august 25, 2011 was a linguist who developed the dynamicequivalence bible translation theory and one of the founders of the modern discipline of translation studies. Sayyab translation studies series stss the aim of sayyab translation studies series stss is to present a series of books on central issues of intercultural communication through translation andor interpreting. Investigating potential differences that may be caused by the structure of language 1905 words 8 pages. The importance of componential analysis in translating or. Books on bible translation page 2 baptist christian forums. The use of componential analysis in translation slideshare. In the previous studies, papers relating translation to componential analysis were not the majority. Ali almanna is founding director of sayyab books london as well as founder of sayyab translation studies series and sayyab translation journal.
In addition, he as recently developed research interest in some modes of interpretation as an empirical field of study. One of the prime elements of componential analysis is the notion of binary opposites, for example. Componential analysis is a way proposed by the structural semanticists to analyze word meaning. Oct 17, 2019 dictionary of translation studies, by mark shuttleworth and moira cowie routledge, 1997 is an excellent resource for bible translators. Department of translation abstract this study aims to give an account for the subject of componential analysis of meaning as it is considered to be an important approach to the study of meaning. This book assesses both sides of the relationship, tracing the very real contributions that linguists have made to translation studies and at the same time recognizing the limitations of. The book first presents key concepts in semantics, pragmatics, semiotics, syntax and morphology and gradually introduces readers to the central. Semantic fields word relations connotation word meaning and translation.
88 973 569 826 953 1449 1423 238 839 74 712 148 1117 754 316 1006 519 112 1401 624 1495 1127 972 1177 178 1370 1239 1530 663 304 576 343 697 619 261 854 610 1378 1018 775